Thinking about adding a carport to your home but unsure which material to choose? You’re not alone. Many homeowners face this exact decision when weighing up practicality, longevity, and appearance. Whether you’re safeguarding a classic car, freeing up garage space, or simply upgrading your property, the choice between a timber carport and a metal one deserves careful thought.

This guide compares oak timber carports with metal and aluminium alternatives, highlighting key factors like strength, visual appeal, eco impact, installation, and long-term value. If you’re in Lutterworth or the Midlands and exploring your options, read on.

Why Your Carport Choice Matters 

A well-designed carport isn’t just about protection from the weather—it’s an investment in your property. In places like Leicester, Coventry, and Rugby, where properties often blend modern builds with rural charm, the material you choose will significantly influence kerb appeal and resale value.

If you’ve ever seen a gleaming car parked under a dented aluminium canopy, you’ll understand the importance of matching aesthetics with function. Many of our clients in Lutterworth opt for timber because they’re not just building shelter—they’re adding character and usability to their home. The choice of carport installation comes down to what matters most: style, strength, maintenance, or price.

Timber vs. Metal Carports – A Closer Look

Let’s break it down into clear, comparable points. Each material has its pros and cons, but you may find the winner becomes obvious depending on your priorities.

1. Durability & Strength

Timber (especially oak):

• Naturally robust and resilient to heavy weather
• Resistant to minor knocks and dents
• Lasts for decades when well-treated
• Maintains integrity even after years of outdoor exposure

Metal (steel or aluminium):

• Steel is strong, but prone to rust unless powder-coated
  
• Aluminium is lightweight but dents easily
  
• May require more ongoing protection from corrosion
• Prone to wear in coastal or high-humidity areas
  

Verdict: Timber wins for long-term strength without ongoing protective treatments.

2. Appearance & Style

Timber Carports:

• Seamlessly match rural, period, and modern homes
  
• Provide warmth, elegance, and architectural interest
  
• Can be customised with trusses, cladding, and detail work
  
• Patinas beautifully over time or can be stained to taste
  

Metal Carports:

• Tend to look more utilitarian
• Limited design options
  
• Often lack aesthetic harmony with traditional homes

Verdict: Timber is a clear winner for homeowners wanting structure and style.

3. Installation & Flexibility

Timber Carports:

• Designed to spec, often pre-assembled to reduce site time
• Can be adapted for workshops, log stores, or side rooms
• Installed by experienced carport installers with traditional joinery skills
  

Metal Carports:

• Often modular, DIY or kit-based
• Limited adaptability for custom needs or integration with extensions
• Fast installation, but usually lacks custom support
  

Verdict: Metal wins for speed, but timber wins for flexibility and quality craftsmanship.

4. Eco-Friendliness & Sustainability

Timber Carports (from Oaksmiths):

• Built using PEFC-certified oak—responsibly sourced and renewable
  
• Lower carbon footprint compared to processed metal
  
• Lasts longer, reducing waste
  

Metal Carports:

• Aluminium production is energy-intensive
• May be recyclable, but involves more emissions in manufacturing
• Often imported, increasing the carbon footprint
  

Verdict: Timber is the more environmentally responsible choice.

5. Long-Term Value & Cost

Timber Carports:

• Higher upfront cost but adds property value
• Minimal maintenance if the oak is treated by the client—though not essential, treatment can help maintain colour, and maintenance requirements remain low either way.
• Lasts for generations

Metal Carports:

• Lower initial cost
• May degrade faster, especially in exposed locations
• Less likely to add long-term value to the home

Verdict: Timber offers better return on investment over time.